By signing in you confirm you are 18 or older, or have your parent’s or guardian’s consent.

CTET 7 Jul 2024 Paper 1, Question 33

Topic: Children's errors in maths

Q33

Students in a class are solving questions based on percentage discounts. One question requires the students to calculate the cost of two bikes, with a 8%8\% discount on each bike. One of the groups calculates the total cost of the bikes and then deducts 16%16\% from the total cost. The method used by this group is :

  1. (1) Correct and is the only way to calculate the discount and cost.
  2. (2) An alternate strategy to solve the question.
  3. (3) False, since they have deducted 16%16\% discount from the total instead of 8%8\%.Correct answer
  4. (4) False, since they have deducted 16%16\% from the total instead of 16%16\% from the average of the total.

Solution.

CBSE answer: (3)

Answer: (3) False, they deducted 16% instead of 8%

  1. Let the bikes cost aa and bb. 8% off each gives 0.92a+0.92b=0.92(a+b)0.92a + 0.92b = 0.92(a+b).
  2. So the discount on the total is still 8%8\%; percentages on separate items do not add up.
  3. Deducting 16%16\% gives 0.84(a+b)0.84(a+b), which is too low.

Trap: Option (2) treats the error as an alternate strategy, but it gives a wrong amount.