By signing in you confirm you are 18 or older, or have your parent’s or guardian’s consent.

CTET 7 Jul 2024 Paper 1, Question 28

Topic: Kohlberg

Q28

When presented with Heinz’s dilemma, Arunima reasons : “The law wasn’t set up for these circumstances. Taking the drug in this situation isn’t really right, but it’s justified.”
Which stage of moral development is Arunima according to the theory of Lawrence Kohlberg ?

  1. (1) Social concern and conscience
  2. (2) Morality of contrast, of individual rights and of democraticallyCorrect answer
  3. (3) Orientation towards punishment and obedience accepted law
  4. (4) Instrumental purpose and exchange

Solution.

CBSE answer: (2)

Answer: (2) Morality of contract, individual rights and democratically accepted law

  1. Option (2) is misprinted ('contrast', with 'accepted law' slipped into option (3)); it names Kohlberg's Stage 5, social contract.
  2. Arunima sees that laws are made by people for the common good and can be set aside when they fail a human need, like saving a life.
  3. This view of law as a flexible social contract is Kohlberg's Stage 5, in the post-conventional level.
  4. Social concern and conscience (1) is Stage 4, which holds that laws must be obeyed; (3) and (4) are the pre-conventional Stages 1 and 2.

Trap: "isn't really right" may suggest Stage 4, but she still finds the act justified.