Q2
Write arguments for and against each of the following statements :
- 40 marks
(a)
The concept of work-life balance is a myth.
- 20 marks
How it is marked, Q2 (a) What earns marks Marks Arguments for: at least four distinct, reasoned points with examples 8 Arguments against: at least four distinct, reasoned points with examples 8 Balance, a short conclusion and clear language 4 - For: always-on smartphones and remote work blur office and home; long hours culture and job insecurity; gig workers have no fixed hours; women carry a double burden of paid and unpaid work
- Against: many firms adopt flexible hours, leave policies and right-to-disconnect ideas; laws on working hours and maternity leave; balance is a matter of choices and boundaries; productivity research shows rested workers perform better
Arguments for the statement
- Technology has removed the boundary between office and home. Email and messaging apps keep employees reachable at night and on holidays, so work rarely stops.
- In competitive sectors long hours are treated as a sign of commitment. Fear of losing a job or a promotion pushes people to work beyond their limits.
- Gig and platform workers, a growing share of the workforce, have no fixed hours, paid leave or social security, so balance is out of their reach.
- Working women often carry most of the housework and care of children and elders as well. For them the idea of balance can sound hollow.
- Rising stress, burnout and lifestyle diseases among young professionals suggest that the promise of balance is not being kept.
Arguments against the statement
- Many employers now offer flexible hours, hybrid work, wellness leave and crèches, showing that balance can be designed into jobs.
- Laws set limits: the labour codes regulate working hours and overtime, and the Maternity Benefit Act gives 26 weeks of paid leave.
- Studies show that rested employees are more productive and creative, so balance serves the employer's interest too, and firms are acting on it.
- Balance is partly in individual hands: setting priorities, saying no to unnecessary work and protecting time for family and health.
- Several countries have adopted a right to disconnect after work hours, showing that the idea can be made real by policy.
Conclusion
Work-life balance is hard to achieve, especially for informal workers and women, but it is not a myth. It needs fair workplace policies, legal protection and personal discipline working together.(b)
Gene editing is a threat to human identity.
- 20 marks
How it is marked, Q2 (b) What earns marks Marks Arguments for: at least four distinct, reasoned points with examples 8 Arguments against: at least four distinct, reasoned points with examples 8 Balance, a short conclusion and clear language 4 - For: germline editing changes heredity for future generations; designer babies and eugenics; inequality between the edited and unedited; unknown long-term effects; He Jiankui case 2018
- Against: identity rests on values, culture and choices, not a few genes; somatic editing cures diseases (sickle cell therapy Casgevy approved); strict regulation possible; medicine has always altered biology (vaccines, transplants)
Arguments for the statement
- Editing the germline (eggs, sperm or embryos) changes the genes passed to every later generation. Humanity would be altering its own inheritance without the consent of those not yet born.
- Once traits such as height, intelligence or appearance can be chosen, "designer babies" and a new form of eugenics become possible.
- Gene editing will be costly, so the rich may buy genetic advantages, dividing society into the enhanced and the natural.
- The long-term effects of edits, including changes at the wrong place in the genome, are not known. The 2018 birth of gene-edited twins in China alarmed scientists worldwide.
- Diversity, including disability and difference, is part of what makes us human. Editing it away could narrow the idea of a normal person.
Arguments against the statement
- Human identity rests on consciousness, values, culture, relationships and choices, not on a few genes. Correcting a faulty gene does not change who a person is.
- Somatic gene editing treats only the patient. Therapies based on CRISPR have already been approved for sickle cell disease, and India has its own programme against the disease.
- Medicine has always changed the body, through vaccines, transplants and hormone therapy, without destroying identity. Gene editing is the next step in healing.
- Strong laws and ethics boards can permit therapy while banning enhancement and germline changes, as India's guidelines and many countries already do.
- Gene editing can reduce human suffering from inherited diseases such as thalassaemia, which is itself a moral good.
Conclusion
Gene editing is a powerful tool rather than a threat in itself. Used for treatment under strict rules, it can protect human dignity; used for enhancement without limits, it could endanger it.