By signing in you confirm you are 18 or older, or have your parent’s or guardian’s consent.

CAPF AC 2026 Paper 2, question 2

Topic: Arguments for and against

Q2

Write arguments for and against each of the following statements :

  • 40 marks
  1. (a)

    The concept of work-life balance is a myth.

    • 20 marks
    How it is marked, Q2 (a)
    What earns marksMarks
    Arguments for: at least four distinct, reasoned points with examples8
    Arguments against: at least four distinct, reasoned points with examples8
    Balance, a short conclusion and clear language4

    Key points

    • For: always-on smartphones and remote work blur office and home; long hours culture and job insecurity; gig workers have no fixed hours; women carry a double burden of paid and unpaid work
    • Against: many firms adopt flexible hours, leave policies and right-to-disconnect ideas; laws on working hours and maternity leave; balance is a matter of choices and boundaries; productivity research shows rested workers perform better

    Our model answer

    Arguments for the statement

    1. Technology has removed the boundary between office and home. Email and messaging apps keep employees reachable at night and on holidays, so work rarely stops.
    2. In competitive sectors long hours are treated as a sign of commitment. Fear of losing a job or a promotion pushes people to work beyond their limits.
    3. Gig and platform workers, a growing share of the workforce, have no fixed hours, paid leave or social security, so balance is out of their reach.
    4. Working women often carry most of the housework and care of children and elders as well. For them the idea of balance can sound hollow.
    5. Rising stress, burnout and lifestyle diseases among young professionals suggest that the promise of balance is not being kept.

    Arguments against the statement

    1. Many employers now offer flexible hours, hybrid work, wellness leave and crèches, showing that balance can be designed into jobs.
    2. Laws set limits: the labour codes regulate working hours and overtime, and the Maternity Benefit Act gives 26 weeks of paid leave.
    3. Studies show that rested employees are more productive and creative, so balance serves the employer's interest too, and firms are acting on it.
    4. Balance is partly in individual hands: setting priorities, saying no to unnecessary work and protecting time for family and health.
    5. Several countries have adopted a right to disconnect after work hours, showing that the idea can be made real by policy.

    Conclusion
    Work-life balance is hard to achieve, especially for informal workers and women, but it is not a myth. It needs fair workplace policies, legal protection and personal discipline working together.

  2. (b)

    Gene editing is a threat to human identity.

    • 20 marks
    How it is marked, Q2 (b)
    What earns marksMarks
    Arguments for: at least four distinct, reasoned points with examples8
    Arguments against: at least four distinct, reasoned points with examples8
    Balance, a short conclusion and clear language4

    Key points

    • For: germline editing changes heredity for future generations; designer babies and eugenics; inequality between the edited and unedited; unknown long-term effects; He Jiankui case 2018
    • Against: identity rests on values, culture and choices, not a few genes; somatic editing cures diseases (sickle cell therapy Casgevy approved); strict regulation possible; medicine has always altered biology (vaccines, transplants)

    Our model answer

    Arguments for the statement

    1. Editing the germline (eggs, sperm or embryos) changes the genes passed to every later generation. Humanity would be altering its own inheritance without the consent of those not yet born.
    2. Once traits such as height, intelligence or appearance can be chosen, "designer babies" and a new form of eugenics become possible.
    3. Gene editing will be costly, so the rich may buy genetic advantages, dividing society into the enhanced and the natural.
    4. The long-term effects of edits, including changes at the wrong place in the genome, are not known. The 2018 birth of gene-edited twins in China alarmed scientists worldwide.
    5. Diversity, including disability and difference, is part of what makes us human. Editing it away could narrow the idea of a normal person.

    Arguments against the statement

    1. Human identity rests on consciousness, values, culture, relationships and choices, not on a few genes. Correcting a faulty gene does not change who a person is.
    2. Somatic gene editing treats only the patient. Therapies based on CRISPR have already been approved for sickle cell disease, and India has its own programme against the disease.
    3. Medicine has always changed the body, through vaccines, transplants and hormone therapy, without destroying identity. Gene editing is the next step in healing.
    4. Strong laws and ethics boards can permit therapy while banning enhancement and germline changes, as India's guidelines and many countries already do.
    5. Gene editing can reduce human suffering from inherited diseases such as thalassaemia, which is itself a moral good.

    Conclusion
    Gene editing is a powerful tool rather than a threat in itself. Used for treatment under strict rules, it can protect human dignity; used for enhancement without limits, it could endanger it.

Practise and get marked

Write one answer at a time and get marks for it. Sign in with Google to start.

By signing in you confirm you are 18 or older, or have your parent’s or guardian’s consent.