By signing in you confirm you are 18 or older, or have your parent’s or guardian’s consent.

CAPF AC 2025 Paper 2, question 5

Topic: Comprehension

Q5

Read the following passage and answer the questions that follow :

  • 20 marks

Passage · Q5

The international state system and the modern state, as we know it today, is rather young. The treaty of Westphalia of 1648 is said to be the beginning of the system of sovereign states. But what sort of a system existed prior to Westphalia and why historians and scholars of International Relations (IR) consider it fundamental is important to understand. The modern state, with defined political borders and sovereignty, was an alien concept till the sixteenth century. Pre- and post-Westphalia, several things have remained unchanged. Wars were fought and peace treaties were signed. But the treaty of Westphalia drew up a list of core principles, which redefined the conception of the state. Huge empires sprawled across the globe and dynasties frequently changed. Political boundaries were almost fluid, being drawn and violated repeatedly. Territories were often cut up and divided amongst allies or appropriated.

The treaty of Westphalia revised this completely. Territories were fixed and marked as inviolable. Sovereignty of the state or supremacy of the state became an accepted norm. These developments facilitated the growth of international relations, for now states could conduct relations and maintain ties as clearly identified actors; no longer did the states constantly changed their role. The treaty of Westphalia was strengthened with two major turns in history: the birth of the American nation and the French Revolution. Both lent the treaty certain credibility and deepened the norm of sovereignty and territorial inviolability.

When the Americans snapped ties with Great Britain after the much publicised and historic Boston Tea Party and declared that they were an independent nation, the idea that a nation is possible without a royal ruling dynasty was perpetuated. The French Revolution carried on the short history of breaking links with the past and rejecting the ancient regime. The cry of “Liberty, Equality and Fraternity” spelt the death knell of not only Marie Antoinette, the young French empress, but also the traditional social structure of France. The idea that society was divided into classes was overturned and replaced with that of fraternity. The idea of a Republic was revolutionary in 1789 and was poised to spread across Europe.

The growth of international law is closely related to the simultaneous conceptualisation of state sovereignty. International law could be defined as a code of conduct, which states adhere to, both in times of war and peace. The body of international law as we know it today, has been evolving for the last four or five hundred years in Europe. The term international law, first used by Jeremy Bentham in 1780, was used to express the “law of states” and its primary purpose was to regulate the relations between states. This law and its consequent obligations have been accepted by states. It not only outlines the rights and duties of states, but also provides means to amicably resolve disputes between states.

  1. (a)

    What sort of a state system existed prior to Westphalia ?

    • 4 marks
    How it is marked, Q5 (a)
    What earns marksMarks
    Correct facts from the passage: large empires and frequently changing dynasties; fluid borders drawn and violated repeatedly; territories divided among allies or seized; no modern state with fixed borders and sovereignty3
    Answer in complete sentences, in the candidate's own words1

    Key points

    • large empires and frequently changing dynasties; fluid borders drawn and violated repeatedly; territories divided among allies or seized; no modern state with fixed borders and sovereignty

    Our model answer

    Before Westphalia there was no system of sovereign states with fixed borders. Huge empires spread across the world, dynasties changed often, and political boundaries were fluid, being drawn and broken again and again, while territories were divided among allies or simply seized.

  2. (b)

    What core principles did the treaty of Westphalia draw up ?

    • 4 marks
    How it is marked, Q5 (b)
    What earns marksMarks
    Correct facts from the passage: territories fixed and inviolable; sovereignty (supremacy) of the state accepted as a norm3
    Answer in complete sentences, in the candidate's own words1

    Key points

    • territories fixed and inviolable; sovereignty (supremacy) of the state accepted as a norm

    Our model answer

    The treaty of Westphalia (1648) laid down that state territories were fixed and could not be violated, and that the sovereignty, or supremacy, of each state was an accepted norm.

  3. (c)

    How did Westphalia facilitate the growth of international relations ?

    • 4 marks
    How it is marked, Q5 (c)
    What earns marksMarks
    Correct facts from the passage: states became clearly identified actors with fixed territory and sovereignty, so they could conduct relations and maintain ties without constantly changing roles3
    Answer in complete sentences, in the candidate's own words1

    Key points

    • states became clearly identified actors with fixed territory and sovereignty, so they could conduct relations and maintain ties without constantly changing roles

    Our model answer

    By fixing borders and accepting state sovereignty, Westphalia turned states into clearly identified and stable actors. They no longer kept changing their roles, so they could build and maintain regular relations and ties with one another.

  4. (d)

    How did the birth of the American nation and the French Revolution lend credibility to the treaty of Westphalia ?

    • 4 marks
    How it is marked, Q5 (d)
    What earns marksMarks
    Correct facts from the passage: American independence showed a nation could exist without a royal dynasty; the French Revolution broke with the old regime, replacing class with fraternity and spreading the republican idea; both deepened sovereignty and territorial inviolability3
    Answer in complete sentences, in the candidate's own words1

    Key points

    • American independence showed a nation could exist without a royal dynasty; the French Revolution broke with the old regime, replacing class with fraternity and spreading the republican idea; both deepened sovereignty and territorial inviolability

    Our model answer

    American independence showed that a nation could exist without a royal dynasty, and the French Revolution, with its call for liberty, equality and fraternity, rejected the old order and spread the idea of a republic. Together they strengthened the norms of sovereignty and territorial integrity laid down at Westphalia.

  5. (e)

    How was international law conceptualized for the first time ?

    • 4 marks
    How it is marked, Q5 (e)
    What earns marksMarks
    Correct facts from the passage: it grew alongside state sovereignty; Jeremy Bentham first used the term in 1780 to mean the 'law of states', meant to regulate relations between states; a code of conduct in war and peace setting rights and duties and means to settle disputes3
    Answer in complete sentences, in the candidate's own words1

    Key points

    • it grew alongside state sovereignty; Jeremy Bentham first used the term in 1780 to mean the 'law of states', meant to regulate relations between states; a code of conduct in war and peace setting rights and duties and means to settle disputes

    Our model answer

    International law developed together with the idea of state sovereignty. The term was first used by Jeremy Bentham in 1780 to mean the 'law of states', whose main purpose was to regulate relations between states, as a code of conduct in war and peace that sets their rights and duties and offers peaceful ways to settle disputes.

Practise and get marked

Write one answer at a time and get marks for it. Sign in with Google to start.

By signing in you confirm you are 18 or older, or have your parent’s or guardian’s consent.