By signing in you confirm you are 18 or older, or have your parent’s or guardian’s consent.

CAPF AC 2025 Paper 2, question 2

Topic: Arguments for and against

Q2

Write arguments for and against each of the following statements :

  • 40 marks
  1. (a)

    A nuclear weapon is a deterrent to warfare

    • 20 marks
    How it is marked, Q2 (a)
    What earns marksMarks
    Arguments for: at least four distinct, reasoned points with examples8
    Arguments against: at least four distinct, reasoned points with examples8
    Balance, a short conclusion and clear language4

    Key points

    • For: no war between nuclear powers since 1945 (Cold War 'long peace'), mutually assured destruction, deters invasion of small nuclear states, India's credible minimum deterrence and no-first-use
    • Against: wars below the nuclear threshold (Kargil 1999), proxy war and terrorism, risk of accident or miscalculation (Cuban Missile Crisis), proliferation and terrorists, huge costs, humanitarian catastrophe, Ukraine war shows nuclear threats used for coercion

    Our model answer

    Arguments for the statement

    1. Since 1945 no two nuclear-armed states have fought a full-scale war against each other. The fear of mutual destruction kept the Cold War from turning hot.
    2. Nuclear weapons make the cost of aggression unacceptable. A rational leader will not risk the destruction of his own cities for a limited gain.
    3. They allow smaller or weaker states to deter larger neighbours, reducing the temptation of conventional invasion.
    4. India's doctrine of credible minimum deterrence and no first use shows how nuclear weapons can be held for defence and stability rather than attack.

    Arguments against the statement

    1. Nuclear weapons have not ended war; they have shifted it below the nuclear threshold. The Kargil conflict of 1999 and continuing cross-border terrorism happened between two nuclear states.
    2. Some states use the nuclear shield to wage proxy wars or to threaten others, as seen in nuclear warnings during the Ukraine war.
    3. Deterrence depends on rational leaders and perfect systems. Accidents, false alarms or miscalculation, such as during the Cuban Missile Crisis of 1962, could cause catastrophe.
    4. The spread of weapons to more states, and the risk of terrorists obtaining them, makes the world more dangerous.
    5. The huge cost and the certainty of mass civilian deaths make nuclear deterrence morally troubling.

    Conclusion
    Nuclear weapons have helped prevent major wars between great powers, but they have not stopped conflict and carry the risk of disaster. Deterrence must be backed by arms control, risk reduction and the long-term goal of disarmament.

  2. (b)

    The use of artificial intelligence is unavoidable today

    • 20 marks
    How it is marked, Q2 (b)
    What earns marksMarks
    Arguments for: at least four distinct, reasoned points with examples8
    Arguments against: at least four distinct, reasoned points with examples8
    Balance, a short conclusion and clear language4

    Key points

    • For: embedded in search, maps, banking fraud checks, healthcare diagnosis, agriculture advisories, governance (Bhashini, IndiaAI Mission), economic competitiveness, national security
    • Against: human judgement still essential, risks of bias, job loss, privacy, deepfakes, energy use, digital divide; many tasks and people still function without AI; use should be a choice and regulated

    Our model answer

    Arguments for the statement

    1. AI already runs much of daily life, often unseen: search engines, maps, spam filters, bank fraud checks and recommendations on phones all use it.
    2. In healthcare, AI helps read scans and detect diseases early; in farming, it gives weather and pest advice; in governance, tools like Bhashini translate services into Indian languages.
    3. Businesses that do not adopt AI lose out in productivity and cost to competitors, so the economy cannot afford to stay away from it.
    4. Countries are investing heavily in AI for defence and security. India's IndiaAI Mission shows that no nation wants to be left behind.
    5. Huge volumes of data in modern society cannot be handled without automated analysis.

    Arguments against the statement

    1. Many important decisions, in courts, medicine and policing, still need human judgement, empathy and accountability, which AI cannot supply.
    2. AI can be biased, invade privacy, spread deepfakes and displace workers, so its use should be limited where the harm is greater than the benefit.
    3. Large parts of India still lack reliable internet and digital skills; millions live and work without AI, showing it is not truly unavoidable.
    4. AI systems consume large amounts of energy and water, raising environmental concerns.
    5. Treating AI as unavoidable can encourage blind adoption without proper rules and safeguards.

    Conclusion
    AI has become a central part of modern life and the economy, and avoiding it altogether is no longer realistic. Its use, however, must be a careful choice, guided by regulation, ethics and human oversight.

Practise and get marked

Write one answer at a time and get marks for it. Sign in with Google to start.

By signing in you confirm you are 18 or older, or have your parent’s or guardian’s consent.